Monday, October 31, 2011

Stumbling from Point A to Point B

"How?"
That is the biggest question on my mind as I begin to think about implementing technology and ensuring student engagement in my future classroom.
Tracy J. Tarasiuk describes the dichotomy between the mindset of traditional literacy and contemporary literacy: "In [the traditional literacy mindset], scarcity and production of goods is valued.  This is the mind-set that exists in most large institutions, such as schools. The second mind-set (contemporary literacy) conceives of literacy . . . involving ICT. Participation and dispersal of goods and information is valued. This is the mind-set of our students."

So, students today are "plugged in."  They are more often to be found browsing the web than flipping pages in a book.  Yet, schools continue to teach a stagnant literacy that undervalues the technological literacy that students master.  Of course, this is ridiculous!  Literacy is evolving and expanding; schools are not.

This all makes sense, and I embrace the necessary changes whole-heartedly.  (The "changes" being the ends of the contemporary literacy mentioned above.)

However, as Tarasiuk so eloquently stated, "What we are less certain about, and certainly less knowledgeable about, is the particular focus that facilitative support should take."

In this lies my unrest.  I can define this contemporary literacy.  I can explain its benefits - referencing studies, models, and research in different scholarly articles.  I can argue a case for how it is better able to engage students than previous methods.  I have the theory down, but what does it look like in practice?

This ties back into a discussion we had much earlier in the semester.  We recognized that our classrooms need to be different than the English classrooms we experienced.  However, we expressed worries about returning to the old methods that we were taught with because that is what we knew.  I do not know what an English classroom based around a contemporary literacy looks like because I have never experienced it.

I like the Wiki pages and book trailers that Tarasiuk implemented.  I think the power of websites and other online resources is that they allow the students to create something, and through this creation to express their ideas.  It gives student voices a lot of power, particularly on a resource that connects to the entire world.

I gather that a lot of my unrest about working with a contemporary literacy will fade when I actually interact with it and experience it within my classroom.  This is humbling again because it reminds me that teaching will not be easy.  In order to be an effective teacher, I will not be able to slip into a groove.  Each year, I will need to be stretching myself to engage a new and unique group of minds that are a part of an ever-evolving literacy.  It is a beautiful and exciting future, and I look forward to it (despite the inevitable challenges).

Another challenge will be reconnecting students to literature.  Mark Bauerlein details the literacy gender gap; his research suggests that male students are less likely to read than female students.  One reason that he expounds is that schools push texts that disengage male students.  We have discussed this in class before, too, determining that it is most important to teach texts that will engage students.  Again, this is a challenge that will require me to move away from the traditional canons; I will teach students, not books.

I feel as though I reach the same conclusion with the completion of each post.  Teaching English is no cake walk because it is a profession that is always evolving to meet the ever changing needs of each new generation.

4 comments:

  1. "Literacy is evolving and expanding; schools are not." Yes! Exactly!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with the quote Dr. Mortimore-Smith mentioned! I was actually about to quote it in my comment to you. We are growing up in a completely different era than our parents did. We have access to many tools that they did not. I think because the media gives social networking and search engines a bad name it cannot be viewed as an education tool to many school districts and parents. In a way I think the best people to judge how these tools can be used is us. We are the people who use them the most. If we can connect our students to the things that interests them learning will come at ease and start to become enjoyable!

    ReplyDelete
  3. You raise a great question: "What does contemporary literacy look like in practice?" And as you said, I haven't really seen this in practice, either. We've been given good examples in class, but it's going to look different in other types of classes. One question I was asked in my interview at HACC was, "How will you incorporate technology into the classroom?" And although I consider myself a pretty tech-savvy person, I was stumped by this question. I could name different types of technology I could use, but I couldn't really "see" how it could be used effectively.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sarah, you ask really good questions in regard to the use of technology in the classroom. I can really relate when you say that teaching "will be no cake walk" because I feel that I am coming from behind in the use of computer technology. Tarasiuk's article was helpful in that she mentioned she was being taught by her students also. At the same time, other writers have said we teachers should expect students to be the "experts" at technology. But, I think Tarasiuk must have been a really good teacher and was able to balance between students who use computers for literacy and those who do not. For beginning teachers, I think it is very important to teach it because like Dr. Shannon noted schools have been lagging behind and it is necessary for students to effectively learn to use social media in the world today. I can personally attest to the frustration of lacking computer skills to do necessary tasks and I believe that translate directly to skills necessary in the job market. I hope I can effectively get students to make this connection and use it in literacy learning.

    ReplyDelete